Buyers' Guide Reviewby Martin Izsak |
(A more in-depth analysis, containing "SPOILERS" and intended for those who have already seen the program, can be accessed here.) |
Russell T. Davies is back writing his
fourth Doctor Who Christmas Special in as many years,
turning out a fairly successful little adventure without it becoming
anything too groundbreaking or extravagant.
The TARDIS starts the adventure off right for the first time in a long
time, giving us a good solid materialization to begin with, and a proper
interior/exterior demonstration later on. Full marks.
And the setting is largely an enjoyable success as well. After giving us a good dose of alien planets during the last few stories, coming back to London, England has regained its charming place in Doctor Who's variety. This tale also boasts the most successful Christmas atmosphere of any of the program's recent Yuletide specials, primarily by coming back to the industrializing Charles Dickens era of 1851 from which so many other Christmas stories and programs take their cue. It helps evoke the nostalgia for those simpler by-gone times when one takes a break from routine to focus on family and good will. We also get a decent dose of snow, both on the ground and freshly falling, something that appeared all too sparingly when previous specials were idiotically shot in the middle of summer.
|
David Tennant's Doctor nicely goes through a whole sequence full of
the logical reactions to meeting future versions of himself that was usually
denied other returning Doctors during previous multi-Doctor specials.
New Doctor David Morrissey has a decent crack at embodying the title role
here. I suspect he might make a good Doctor, yet not one of my top
favourites as Tennant and the first five have managed.
And we do see some of the fun that existed in past multi-Doctor
adventures.
Our villains have a human co-conspirator in this adventure, as they often do, and not surprisingly Davies turns yet again to a woman for the part. Is he playing it safe once again? She certainly isn't the most interesting character we've seen on the show.... |
|
The cybermen make good returning villains in this story, well-matched to the industrialization theme in the story that opposes the Christmas ideal. And it's actually ironic now that one actually wants both to get the nostalgic Christmas atmosphere right. The Cyber Leader has a new look to differentiate himself from the others, which is good. But I think it goes a bit too far in one way....
The story's weakest point is probably in the new black furry cybercreatures, mostly because they really don't make enough sense. You be the judge.
Although suffering a bit of a slump in the middle sections, we do at least get some successful mid-story action stratagems during several sequences. Not bad. But it really is the final sequence that pulls out the stops and makes the story really exciting once again, coming to a very satisfying finish that gives the Doctor all the right things to do. And the wrap-up is very satisfying as well. Good job.
In the end, this is a decent and modest little adventure. Although
"Voyage of the Damned" (story no. 193) is
still a better story, this one probably suits the notion of
Christmas Special a bit better, noting also that Christmas Specials are not
the ideal vehicle for good Doctor Who adventures in the first place.
This story is miles ahead of both
"The Christmas Invasion" (story no. 171) and
"The Runaway Bride" (story no. 182),
and proves once again that good Doctor Who Christmas Specials are possible.
And to all a good night!
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
| DVD NTSC Region 1
5-episode box set for the North American market:
in the U.S.
in Canada
|
DVD PAL Region 2
5-episode box set for the U.K.
|
Standard DVD
1-episode volume
NTSC Region 1 - U.S.
NTSC Region 1 - Canada
PAL Region 2 - U.K.
|
Blu-Ray NTSC Region 1 5-episode box set for the North American market:
in the U.S.
in Canada
|
Blu-Ray PAL Region 2 5-episode box set for the U.K.
|
LYRATEK.COM |
|