State of Decay

DVD NTSC
E-Space Trilogy
Region 1


for North America
DVD PAL
E-Space Trilogy
Region 2

for the U.K.
VHS Video
E-Space Trilogy
NTSC
PAL
(Doctor Who Story No. 113, starring Tom Baker)
  • written by Terrance Dicks
  • directed by Peter Moffatt
  • produced by John Nathan-Turner
  • music by Paddy Kingsland
  • 4 episodes @ 25 minutes each
Story: Still searching for a way out of E-space, the Doctor, Romana, K9, and their new stowaway find themselves on a planet with a medieval culture. The Doctor is aghast to learn that their science is regressing instead of advancing, and that the nocturnal ruling trio seems to like things that way. Evidence of vampires in the castle tower mounts, until the origins of the population are revealed, along with the identity of a creature that they all serve which the Doctor's people have pledged him to destroy....

DVD Extras include:

  • Audio commentary by writer Terrance Dicks, director Peter Moffatt, and actor Matthew Waterhouse (Adric).
  • The Making of State of Decay featurette (20 min), with Dicks, Moffatt, Lalla Ward (Romana), John Leeson (Voice of K9),
    Clinton Greyn (Ivo), designer Christine Ruscoe, and script editor Christopher H. Bidmead.
  • Music Only option
  • Photo Gallery music montage (4 min.)
  • Pop-up Production Note Subtitles for main feature AND THE PHOTO GALLERY
  • extra 35mm model film footage (5 min.)
  • "The Frayling Reading" a cultural historian analyzes State of Decay. (4 min.)
  • "Leaves of Blood" history of vampires in fiction (17 min.)
  • symbolism of blood featurette (10 min.)

In-Depth Analysis Review

by Martin Izsak

WARNING: This review contains "SPOILERS", and is intended for those who have already seen the program. To avoid the spoilers, read the Buyers' Guide version instead.


Earlier versions of this story had been kicking around the Doctor Who production offices for three years, apparently always being sent back for revisions and ultimately being passed over in favour of last minute formulaic replacements like "Horror of Fang Rock". But all that extra development time seems to have done the final script some good, even as Leela's role got passed to Romana, and K9 and Adric became expertly woven into the story, at the last minute in Adric's case.

This is the last of Terrance Dicks' adaptations of classic horror films for televised Doctor Who, and in my opinion, his most successful. After "King Kong" became "Robot" (story no. 75), Frankenstein became the abysmal "Brain of Morbius" (story no. 84), and the "Thing in the Lighthouse" concept became "Horror of Fang Rock" (story no. 92), the legends of Dracula and vampires find their feet in the Doctor Who universe through "State of Decay".


Triumph of Structure over Subject Matter

Even though this subject matter, vampires, is not particularly to my tastes, the story has such an expert traditional structure and an appealing execution of a wider variety of elements in the production that I invariably find myself pulled in and absorbed anyway, and willing to give it high marks and a healthy ranking within the season. Congratulations are due to Terrance Dicks for what I feel is his strongest Doctor Who script after "The War Games" (story no. 50).

Notice how expertly the first three episodes stay focused on what I feel is the primary story beat of the science fiction genre - exploration. The first episode is very focused on exploring the setting and the various characters. The Doctor and Romana roam everywhere and establish locations such that we'll be familiar with them when they appear in short scenes in later episodes. The middle episodes then embark on an exploration of the villains and their sinister machinations, concluding with the Doctor elevating them to mythic proportions.

Episode Four then unravels a solution, deals us the action, and delivers an emotionally satisfying ending that is one of the very strongest of the season.


Introductory Pros and Cons

The good stuff takes some time to show itself though. After a satisfying establishing shot of the tower and surroundings with barely passable model work, "State of Decay" opens with three very dodgy scenes showing characters going about their usual business. The exchange between the guard Habris and the ruling trio is quite melodramatic, while the selection in the village (although easily the most interesting of the three opening scenes) also seems quite bizarre and fails to grip. The opening scene of the Doctor and Romana in the TARDIS is, I suspect, grafted on by the current script editor in an attempt to remind audiences of our heroes' need to escape E-space. Although this is a very important writing goal to satisfy, the dialogue is so unnatural, steeped in the kind of mismatching devil's advocate thought patterns that made so many of Bob Baker and Dave Martin's attempts at humorous exposition fall flat, that it is a chore to view.

But after a quick shot of the TARDIS traversing the starry green background of E-Space, the script's focus on exploration begins with the new planet, and the excellence of "State of Decay" sets in.

The TARDIS demonstrates itself with a satisfying materialization, not to mention a "short hop" near the end with some interesting expository dialogue concerning the process, and the interior / exterior relationship is showcased by the Doctor's movements in episodes one, three, and four. Nice. With this being the first story shot in John Nathan-Turner's era as producer that features the TARDIS interior, perhaps we have designer Christine Ruscoe to thank for the lovely iconic corrugated pillars hiding the joins between the wall panels. Excellent. This appears to be the second time Ruscoe has updated the TARDIS interior, after working on "Pyramids of Mars" (story no. 82) and leaving a legacy for "Planet of Evil" (story no. 81), two stories which were also shot out of order.

"State of Decay" is also blessed with a good amount of location filming (always an enjoyable bonus), although this tends to peter out later in the story after the settings are established and the pace needs to tighten up.


Character Lens

Many of the guest characters remain blandly forgettable, even after receiving good performances from the actors. It is due to the writing, and this is partly a story point as well, as certain qualities have been bred out of the peasant population. Sadly this leaves the rebels themselves somewhat less than rousing. Nevertheless, Clinton Greyn is quite sympathetic as Ivo, and his larger stature helps him stand out amongst the crowd. Iain Rattray as Chief Guard Habris puts a solidity into his performance that I believe deserves a lot of credit for holding the believability of the whole story together, as the more daring performances of Tom Baker and the ruling trio become more successful by having his on-the-money presence to play off of. Many attempts at similar scenes during the previous producer's era fell flat due to hammy or lacking reactions from extra or minor characters, but now Habris goes the correct way and everything works so much better. Good job.

Onto the ruling trio, all three get to indulge their passion for acting and get away with being a little weird, and manage to create a villainy unique within the Doctor Who series. That's no small feat. Rachel Davies playing Camilla certainly puts extra into her performance, but Emrys Jones playing Aukon goes for a reverent madness full steam ahead and just manages to avoid going over the top.

Tom Baker is clearly enjoying himself in this one, matching Aukon's weirdness when playing opposite him and remaining equally tasteful, but also having barrels of fun exploring all the other characters, locations, and concepts along the way. Lalla Ward catches a bit of the same bug, and does her best work for the story opposite Baker.

K9 achieves his best showing for season 18 in this tale, formulaically waiting in the TARDIS throughout the first half of the story, but refreshingly taking his rightful turn at fulfilling the traditional function of Doctor's companion from late episode three to early episode four, and having plenty of action and key things to do during the story's conclusion. His improved mobility actually allows him to be seen exiting the police box for the first (and I believe, only) time. Kudos. Matthew Waterhouse's first performance as Adric (this story was shot before the two preceding ones) is one of his better ones. Adric displays a cheeky confidence in this story, a bit of cunning, and pulls off some nice mischievous, humorous moments with a little help from the musical score. A bit more of this kind of charisma, instead of the "shut-down" Adric he later went for, might have helped keep the wrath of many fan critics off of Matthew's back.


Production

Paddy Kingsland's first Doctor Who score plays over this story, and is a beautiful and enjoyable achievement. At times humorous, reverent, or boldly underscoring the action, it features his trademark melodic style and lead synthetic flute instrument sound, evoking nostalgia for this period of the show's history. Excellent.

The directing, cinematography, and special effects for this story are adequate and enjoyable, but don't stand out all that much. Most of the effects in particular are saved for the final episode. The design of the tower and rocket doesn't quite seem to match up with what the script calls for: One of three identical scout ships should detach from the main ship, which stays put to allow the peasants hope of a future launch back to their home, yet visually there seems to be little left of the main ship except an empty husk after the one scout ship slides out of it. It's also not too plausible to think that the rocket could freefall unhindered into the underground cavern without the entire tower blasting off in the first place. Ah well, that's what I get for nitpicking at design. The concept is still awesome. The effects for the creature itself work, barely, while no doubt collecting some criticism from fans who imagined something more impressive or desired to be scared out of their wits.

On the plus side, Dave Chapman gets to do justice to K9's laser once again, while some enjoyable extensive decay sequences steal the show for special effects during the conclusion.


All in all, this is a solid, well-rounded, nicely executed, and enjoyable tale, competing strongly in the season 18 rankings with the more noble scripting aims and imagination of "Full Circle" (the previous story), but just managing to come out ahead.



This story is available on DVD and VHS video as the second adventure of the E-Space Trilogy.
Click on the Amazon symbol for the location nearest you for pricing and availability:

DVD NTSC Region 1
The E-Space Trilogy
for the North American market:
in the U.S.
in Canada
DVD PAL Region 2
The E-Space Trilogy
for the U.K.
VHS Video
The E-Space Trilogy
NTSC in North America
PAL for the U.K.


Comments on this article are welcome. You may contact the author from this page:

Contact page


LYRATEK.COM


Read the In-depth Analysis Review for the next story in the E-Space Trilogy: "Warriors' Gate"



Home Page Site Map Star Trek Sliders Doctor Who Tom Baker Era Episode Guide Catalogue